That looks great! PM me to keep this convo going!

Using the arms and pendulum (and later the face) from Ton's resprite, I redid Cogsworth myself to make him look more consistent with Lumière:

Now that I have the final design for him, I'll just have to find what moves/poses he should have and how he would attack.

@Ton Apart from the pupil spacing, the mugshot does look a bit better. I still won't use it despite the improvements. I wonder if using this method again would still work well in other cases where I'd need such accuracy.

Nice! Now the pendulum actually resembles one, and the new arms look much more like his. My version's body was technically more accurate at the sides, but it was simply too wide. I should've tried to have his head be elliptic since it's not a full circle (which I somehow didn't pay attention to), and the body will be thinner and less rounded as well. Thanks for correcting them.

I'd cut down a bit further on the details. I did a quick edit of Cogsworth and Lumiere's portrait. It's not perfect, but it might be a good jumping-off point.

Because I went for the Robot Master look as opposed to the style of the enemies, I initially thought about going a step further by giving him a Stage Select mugshot and Robot Master name:

This was done by taking a zoomed out (not just "resized") screenshot of his original face, reducing the colours while tracing with pixels and replacing the eyes with Top Man's (with Hard Man's pupils). However, I decided to leave it out and thought calling him "Candle Man" might be misinterpreted as making him an OC.

I've also started on Cogsworth, but I don't like his proportions compared to this (he is in scale, though). He'll have to be redone before work on his sheet could commence:

@Omega Clearly it's Mrs Potts's tea-shooter. :P

Be our guest
Be our guest
Which robot weapon is the weakness?